- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 12:45 AM - edited 07-04-2025 01:06 AM
I've implemented aN approval workflow within our knowledge base.
I would like more info related to "cancelled" state.
What is it for? When?
Today I thought it was only approve or reject action.
Is it linked to version? Or is it ... when an approver already approved the request is not longer required?
Thanks
Solved! Go to Solution.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 02:53 AM
hi @MyleneKM ,
That’s a great question! The "Cancelled" state in a knowledge approval workflow is actually quite useful, but it often gets overlooked because, as you said, we usually think only about "Approved" and "Rejected."
Here’s what it’s really for, in practical terms:
The "Cancelled" state means the approval process was stopped before it could be completed, usually because the request itself is no longer needed.
This might happen, for example, if:
The author or knowledge manager withdraws the request before all approvers finish.
The associated knowledge article version is deleted or replaced by a new draft, making the current approval obsolete.
A process or scripted action determines the request should no longer proceed (e.g., because another approver group took over, or the article was merged).
It isn’t typically something an approver chooses. Instead, it’s usually set automatically by the system or by an admin if the workflow is no longer valid.
Regarding versioning: yes, it can be related! For example, if you submit version 1 of an article for approval, but then make edits that create version 2, the system might cancel the pending approvals for version 1, since it’s now outdated.
So, think of “Cancelled” like this:
✅ It’s not a decision like “Approve” or “Reject,” but rather a way to stop the approval process entirely because the request is no longer relevant.
It helps keep the workflow clean and avoids approving something that the business no longer intends to publish.
If you'd like, I can also help you adjust your workflow to automatically set approvals to "Cancelled" when a new version is created — that’s a common best practice!
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 01:46 AM
Hi @MyleneKM,
if there are for example two approvers and one approves it, then the state of the second approver's approval is "No Longer Required", so the Cancelled state is a different scenario.
You shall review the approval (work)flow. If you find it, please share it here to review it together.
/* If my response wasn’t a total disaster ↙️ ⭐ drop a Kudos or Accept as Solution ✅ ↘️ Cheers! */
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 01:57 AM
Thanks @GlideFather ,
I have maybe an idea...
My article was owned by a knowledge owner group.
This group has been replaced as the one selected for the article was incorrect.
Do you think is part of the CANCELLED task?
In parallel please find my Workflow.
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 02:10 AM
The group replacement could be the reason of it, I cannot tell from "outside" of your project.
Please, in the workflow, open the steps where are changes to the approval state and you might see if there is the "Cancelled" state or not.
Perhaps it could be something else - business rule or scheduled job - that set this Cancelled if it is not approved/rejected in some specific period of time. Please check when the approval was asked and when it was set to cancelled. If it will be in 14, 30 days it could be indication that there is some regular data manipulation.
/* If my response wasn’t a total disaster ↙️ ⭐ drop a Kudos or Accept as Solution ✅ ↘️ Cheers! */
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
07-04-2025 02:53 AM
hi @MyleneKM ,
That’s a great question! The "Cancelled" state in a knowledge approval workflow is actually quite useful, but it often gets overlooked because, as you said, we usually think only about "Approved" and "Rejected."
Here’s what it’s really for, in practical terms:
The "Cancelled" state means the approval process was stopped before it could be completed, usually because the request itself is no longer needed.
This might happen, for example, if:
The author or knowledge manager withdraws the request before all approvers finish.
The associated knowledge article version is deleted or replaced by a new draft, making the current approval obsolete.
A process or scripted action determines the request should no longer proceed (e.g., because another approver group took over, or the article was merged).
It isn’t typically something an approver chooses. Instead, it’s usually set automatically by the system or by an admin if the workflow is no longer valid.
Regarding versioning: yes, it can be related! For example, if you submit version 1 of an article for approval, but then make edits that create version 2, the system might cancel the pending approvals for version 1, since it’s now outdated.
So, think of “Cancelled” like this:
✅ It’s not a decision like “Approve” or “Reject,” but rather a way to stop the approval process entirely because the request is no longer relevant.
It helps keep the workflow clean and avoids approving something that the business no longer intends to publish.
If you'd like, I can also help you adjust your workflow to automatically set approvals to "Cancelled" when a new version is created — that’s a common best practice!